Netflix’s popular series ‘Monster: The Ed Gein Story’ sheds light on the infamous American murderer, Ed Gein, also known as The Butcher of Plainfield. Although Gein has been the inspiration for various fictional characters, this series marks the first time his real-life story is portrayed in a true crime format.
Actor Charlie Hunnam takes on the role of Gein in the show, which delves into key events from the killer’s life, including his relationship with neighbor Adeline Watkins, played by Suzanna Son. The series depicts their tumultuous engagement, with Watkins eventually leaving Wisconsin for New York, ending their connection.
In a controversial twist, the show portrays Watkins as being aware of Gein’s heinous acts, even allegedly influencing his dark interests by providing him with disturbing images. The series captures Watkins publicly discussing Gein’s violent tendencies post his capture, showcasing unsettling moments like Gein proposing with a ring taken from a grave.
The portrayal of their relationship has sparked speculation among viewers about the authenticity of their connection. In contrast to the series, Watkins now denies any romantic involvement with Gein, stating that they only met in 1954, after Gein had already exhibited troubling behavior.
Showrunner Ian Brennan defends including Watkins in the series, highlighting her contradictory statements about their relationship over the years. Watkins had previously claimed a two-decade romance with Gein in a 1957 interview, expressing love for him, a sentiment echoed by her mother, who described Gein as a courteous individual.
Watkins recalls their outings involving movies and visits to local taverns, noting Gein’s preference for milkshakes over alcohol. She mentions engaging in conversations about crime, although not specifically Gein’s crimes, finding the subject matter intriguing.
Despite Watkins’ initial claim of a proposal from Gein in 1955, she later clarified that they were only friends, retracting earlier statements to the media. Gein himself never publicly addressed any relationship with Watkins, leaving the truth of their association uncertain.
The series delves into the complex dynamics between Gein and Watkins, offering a glimpse into a contentious chapter of American true crime history.